Secret Santa questions to ask

The best Secret Santa gift comes from one good question. Here are forty, grouped by what you want to find out. In Hollyhush you can ask any of them anonymously from your reveal page.

Create your group, free

How to ask without giving yourself away

  • Mix a few questions together so it doesn't look like you're shopping.
  • Ask about favorites, not "what do you want?". You'll get more honest, more specific answers.
  • If you ask about sizes, add a reason ("for a cozy thing") so it doesn't read as a clue.
  • Ask one question at a time and wait for the reply.

The three questions that do most of the work

If you only ask three, ask these. First, "what is something you use every day that you would never buy for yourself?" This finds upgrade gifts: a better mug, a nicer notebook. Second, "what snack or drink could you not live without?" Food and drink are safe, welcome and almost never a duplicate. Third, "is there anything you would rather not get?" This protects you from allergies, dislikes and gifts that hit a sore spot.

Ask them in separate messages over a few days. A single message with three questions looks like a survey, and the person will guess something is up. Keep each question light, and thank them for the answer, which keeps the chat going.

Ask your giftee anything, anonymously. Create a group and use the question box. Create your group, free

Questions for work colleagues

  • What is on your desk right now that you wish was nicer?
  • Coffee, tea or neither?
  • Do you eat snacks at your desk? Sweet or salty?
  • Is there a hobby you do outside work?
  • Anything you avoid, such as nuts or scented products?

When your giftee does not answer

Silence is common. People are busy, the question gets buried, or they do not guess it is a game. Wait two days, then try a simpler question that is easy to answer in one word: "Sweet or salty?" is more likely to get a reply than "What are your hobbies?". Check their wishlist, since many people add items there when they do not want to chat. If you still have nothing, fall back on safe categories: a good snack, a warm accessory, a small game or a nice candle. The office guide and the family guide both list gift types that suit those groups, and the anonymous Secret Santa page explains how the chat protects your identity.

Before you buy

Once you have two or three answers, pick a gift that matches one of them and stay inside the budget. A small, well-matched gift beats a big guess. If you started without a group, create one so everyone can ask questions the same way.

Turning answers into a gift

Write down what you learn in one place. A short note with two or three facts, such as "likes dark chocolate, wears size medium, loves running", is enough to build a gift around. Look for overlap between the answer and the budget, then pick one clear item rather than a bundle. If the answer is "I am easy", fall back on their wishlist or ask a different question.

A tidy gift usually has one theme: a hot drink set, a running kit, a night in. Use the answer to choose the theme, then fill it in with small items. That reads as thoughtful even when the total is only $20 or $25.

Favorites

  • What is your favorite snack or sweet?
  • Dark, milk or white chocolate?
  • Coffee, tea or something else?
  • What is your go-to mug like?
  • What is the last thing you bought that you love?
  • Do you have a favorite scent: vanilla, pine, citrus, none?
  • Which shop do you always end up in?
  • What book, show or game are you into right now?

Practical

  • What colors do you wear most?
  • What sizes are you for gloves, socks or hats?
  • Any allergies or things you avoid, such as nuts or fragrance?
  • Do you have a hobby I should know about?
  • What would make your commute or desk nicer?
  • Is there something you'd love but never buy for yourself?
  • Do you prefer something to use up or something to keep?
  • Is there a store where a gift card would be a joy?

Fun

  • If you could have any gadget, what would it be?
  • What is your most-used thing in the kitchen?
  • Cozy night in or night out: which is you?
  • What is your guilty-pleasure treat?
  • Which holiday tradition do you love most?
  • What is the best gift you ever got?
  • Do you like a gift that is funny, thoughtful or luxurious?
  • If I wrapped a mystery item, what should it be for?

Home & style

  • Is there a room you're decorating?
  • Do you light candles, and which ones do you like?
  • What do you keep on your bedside table?
  • Plants: yes, no or please no?
  • Soft blanket or fluffy slippers?
  • What is your favorite pattern or print?
  • Are you a minimalist or a collector?
  • What would you hang on your wall?

Treats & experiences

  • Hot sauce, jam or honey: which one?
  • Do you bake or cook, and what tools would you like?
  • What would you love for a night in: a game, a film, a puzzle?
  • Which sweet treat is a weakness?
  • Do you prefer salty or sweet?
  • Is there a cafe or restaurant you love?
  • Would you like a small experience, like a class or tickets?
  • Do you have a collection I can add to?

Frequently asked questions

Can I ask my giftee questions without them knowing it's me?

Yes. In Hollyhush, your reveal page has an anonymous question box. They see it as from "your Secret Santa" and reply there.

What if they ignore my question?

Check their wishlist and try a simpler question next time. People often reply when it's about food or drink.

What should I never ask?

Anything personal or revealing. Stick to likes, sizes and practical questions.

How many questions should I ask my Secret Santa giftee?

Two to four is plenty. Spread them over several days so it does not look like a survey.

Try it now

A draw takes about a minute. No signup, no email, a private link for everyone.

Create your group, free
  • Couples & exclusions
  • Wishlists & anonymous questions
  • Deletes itself in 60 days

More in: Secret Santa printables and templates →

Ready when you are

Make a draw in a minute. No signup, no email, private links for everyone.