White elephant vs. Secret Santa vs. Yankee swap
White elephant and Yankee swap are the same stealing game with different names. Secret Santa is different: each person is assigned one person to buy for. Use Secret Santa for weeks of planning and white elephant for one fun night.
Side by side
| White elephant | Yankee swap | Secret Santa | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How it works | Open or steal wrapped gifts | Same as white elephant | Buy for one assigned person |
| Gifts | One gift per person, anonymous | One gift per person | One gift per person, personal |
| Planning time | Almost none | Almost none | 2 to 4 weeks |
| Event length | 45 to 90 min | 45 to 90 min | 15 to 30 min to hand out |
| Best group size | 8 to 30 | 8 to 30 | 3 to 50 |
| Fits who | Offices, parties | Families, friends | Teams, families, remote |
| Risk | Hurt feelings from stealing | Same | Mismatched gifts |
How to choose
- If you have one evening, pick white elephant.
- If people are far apart, pick Secret Santa.
- If you want a personal gift, pick Secret Santa.
- If you want laughs and a game, pick white elephant.
- If you have a mixed ages group, consider the dice game or Secret Santa.
Hollyhush runs both: a Secret Santa draw with hidden matches, and a white elephant game night tool. Create your group, free
Which name should you use?
White elephant is the most common US name. Yankee swap is a New England term. Dirty Santa and other names turn up in different regions and families. They all mean the same swap with stealing. If your group cares about the difference, ask; otherwise use whichever name your people know. For the rules, see white elephant rules, Yankee swap rules, and Dirty Santa rules.
Can you combine them?
Yes. Many offices run Secret Santa over several weeks and then add a white elephant at the party for those who want a game. You can also run Secret Santa for the main gift and white elephant for small gifts. If the group wants fewer gifts, use one or the other. For a deeper look at Secret Santa, read what is Secret Santa.
Cost and effort
- White elephant: one gift each, about $20 to $30, no shopping for a specific person.
- Secret Santa: one gift each, similar cost, but shopping needs ideas for a real person.
- Time for the organizer: about 10 minutes for Secret Santa setup, plus a rules message for white elephant.
- Remote groups: Secret Santa is easier. White elephant works with shipped gifts but needs more planning.
A quick decision guide
- Group of 6 to 30 in one room, one evening: white elephant.
- Group spread across cities or time zones: Secret Santa with shipped or digital gifts.
- Group with a wide budget range: Secret Santa, with a low cap, so nobody feels left out.
- Group that loves games and teasing: white elephant with a steal limit.
- Group with kids: Secret Santa, or the dice game for a gentle swap.
- Not sure: run Secret Santa and add a short white elephant at the party. Both are in Hollyhush.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between white elephant and Secret Santa?
In white elephant, everyone brings one gift and players open or steal. In Secret Santa, each person buys for one assigned person.
Is Yankee swap the same as white elephant?
In most groups, yes. Different regions use different names.
Which is better for the office?
Secret Santa for weeks of low pressure, white elephant for one lively party. Many offices do both.
Which is better for remote teams?
Secret Santa, because it does not need everyone in the same room. A virtual white elephant is possible too.
Can you play white elephant and Secret Santa together?
Yes. Some groups do Secret Santa gifts first and add a white elephant game at the party.
Try it now
A draw takes about a minute. No signup, no email, a private link for everyone.
Create your group, free- Couples & exclusions
- Wishlists & anonymous questions
- Deletes itself in 60 days
Ready when you are
Make a draw in a minute. No signup, no email, private links for everyone.