
Cookie exchange rules
In a cookie exchange, each guest bakes one batch of the same cookie, brings it to the party, and goes home with a mix of everyone else's. The simplest rule is to bake a dozen for each guest, plus a few to taste, and take home a dozen different cookies. Use the sign-up sheet below so nobody doubles up.
Secret Santa sign-up sheet
Budget: ______ Sign up by: ____________ Swap date: ____________
| # | Name | Contact (email or phone) | Allergies / notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | |||
| 2 | |||
| 3 | |||
| 4 | |||
| 5 | |||
| 6 | |||
| 7 | |||
| 8 | |||
| 9 | |||
| 10 | |||
| 11 | |||
| 12 | |||
| 13 | |||
| 14 | |||
| 15 | |||
| 16 |
The basic rules
- Each guest bakes one type of cookie, a dozen for each person attending, plus a few extra to sample.
- Everyone brings their cookies packed in a container, with a card listing the name and ingredients.
- At the party, each guest fills their own container with a dozen of different cookies.
- Each guest takes the same number home. Count the cookies ahead so the math works.
- Homemade only. No store-bought dough unless the group agrees.
- Label every cookie with allergens. Use one rule for all: nuts, dairy, gluten, eggs.
Ratios: how many to bake
A simpler version: each guest bakes six dozen and brings them in bags of six. That is enough to share a bag with each person. Check the recipe yield, since it varies. If you do not want to bake that many, set a smaller rule like two cookies per guest per kind, and make a smaller swap.
| Guests | Bake | Bring home |
|---|---|---|
| 6 | About 6 dozen, packed in 6 bags of a dozen | 6 bags of a dozen: one from each baker, including a bag of your own |
| 10 | About 5 dozen, packed in 10 bags of six | 10 bags of six, one from each baker |
| 15 | About 7 to 8 dozen, packed in 15 bags of six | 15 bags of six, one from each baker |
Use the sign-up sheet to assign cookies
The most common problem is five people bringing chocolate chip. Use the printable sign-up sheet on this page to assign cookie types. Print it or share it, and have each guest write a name and cookie type.
Here is how to use it for assignments: list types down the page, such as sugar cookies, gingerbread, shortbread, thumbprints, bark and no-bake. Add a column for allergens. Each guest writes their name beside one type. Once a line is taken, it is gone. Share the finished sheet so everyone sees what is coming.
Need a quick way to invite the group? Create it free and share one link. Create your group, free
Packing and transport
- Pack cookies in a single layer with parchment between layers.
- Use a sturdy tin or a plastic container with a lid.
- Keep soft cookies away from crisp ones so they do not go stale.
- Do not mix frosted cookies with bare ones without a separator.
- Bring a few extra bags or boxes for guests to take their cookies home.
- Keep cookies in a cool place until the party.
Allergy labeling and food safety
Write ingredients on a card at each plate. At minimum, flag the major allergens such as peanuts, tree nuts, milk, eggs, wheat and soy. Add a note if a cookie was baked in a kitchen with nuts. Anyone with a severe allergy should decide for themselves, so give them the information and let them choose. Keep raw-egg items out of the swap, and refrigerate anything with cream cheese frosting.
Ask each guest about allergies on the invite so you can ask bakers to avoid common problems.
Extras that make it better
Add a vote for best cookie, ask for recipe cards to swap, or add a donation drive. Plan a time of about two hours so people can chat. If you are adding a gift swap, see holiday party planning checklist and Secret Santa holiday party ideas. For a simple draw, try the Secret Santa generator.
Cookie exchange rules to copy and send
Paste into the invite or group chat, then change the numbers to fit your party.
Cookie exchange rules: bake one kind of cookie, a dozen for each guest plus a few to sample. Pack them in bags of 6 and label each with the name and ingredients. Homemade only. Tell me about allergies when you reply. Everyone goes home with the same number of cookies.
Cookie exchange: [date], [time], [place]. 1) Pick a cookie from the sign-up sheet so we do not get five of the same. 2) Bake a dozen for each guest, plus 6 extra to sample. 3) Bring them in a tin or box with a card listing ingredients and common allergens (nuts, milk, eggs, wheat, soy). 4) At the party we sample, then everyone fills a container with the same number of cookies from different bakers. 5) Bring a container to take your cookies home. Reply by [date] with your cookie and any allergies.
Reminder: the cookie exchange is on [date]. Bake [number] cookies of the kind you signed up for, label the ingredients and bring a container to take cookies home.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a cookie exchange rules template I can copy?
Yes. The boxes above hold a short and a full version. Copy one into your invite or group chat and fill in the date, place and numbers.
How many cookies do you bring to a cookie exchange?
A common rule is a dozen for each guest, plus a few extra to sample.
How many cookies do you take home?
About a dozen, from different bakers. Count ahead so everyone takes the same number.
How do you avoid duplicates?
Use a sign-up sheet so each guest picks a different cookie type.
How do you label allergens?
Put a card with ingredients at each plate and flag major allergens like nuts, milk, eggs, wheat and soy.
Do cookies have to be homemade?
Most exchanges say yes. Agree ahead if store-bought is allowed.
How long should a cookie exchange last?
About two hours is enough for chatting, swapping and packing.
Try it now
A draw takes about a minute. No signup, no email, a private link for everyone.
Create your group, free- Couples & exclusions
- Wishlists & anonymous questions
- Deletes itself in 60 days
Ready when you are
Make a draw in a minute. No signup, no email, private links for everyone.