
Gift exchange games
Secret Santa is just one way to swap gifts. These 17 formats suit different group sizes, ages and levels of chaos. Pick the one that matches your party.
How to choose a gift exchange game
- Count your group first. Under 6 people, a Secret Santa or a mystery bag game works best. From 6 to 20, white elephant is the classic. Over 20, use a dice game or a low steal limit.
- Think about time. A full white elephant takes about 5 minutes per player. A dice game or left-right story is done in 15 to 25 minutes.
- Think about who is there. Kids and mixed ages prefer games with no stealing. Coworkers often prefer a one-to-one exchange with no surprises. Close friends enjoy chaos.
- Decide whether people can bring their own gift or need to be assigned one. Bring-your-own suits stealing games. Assigned gifts suit Secret Santa.
A quick comparison
| Game | Best group size | Time | Stealing? |
|---|---|---|---|
| White elephant | 6 to 40 | 45 to 90 minutes | Yes |
| Secret Santa | 3 to 50 | Weeks, plus a reveal | No |
| Dice game | 5 to 30 | 20 to 30 minutes | Yes, by roll |
| Pass-the-gift story | 6 to 25 | 10 to 15 minutes | No |
| Reverse white elephant | 6 to 20 | 40 minutes | Yes |
Running the stealing game? Hollyhush handles turn order and the live board. Create your group, free
Running a game with Hollyhush
For Secret Santa, create a group and let the generator handle the draw. For white elephant, the game night tool sets the turn order, enforces the steal limit and shows a live screen for the TV. Both are free for groups up to 50 and need no accounts. If you want the rules before you choose, the white elephant rules page covers every step and the common variations.
Gifts for the game
The right gift depends on the game. For stealing games, bring something useful and well wrapped. The white elephant gift ideas under $25 are tuned to that. For Secret Santa, a wishlist beats a guess, and anonymous questions help.
For kids, keep the budget small and make sure every child gets something, since stealing can end in tears. A mystery gift bag game or a pass-the-gift story is safer than a full steal game for young players.
Make any game better
- Set the budget before anyone shops and say it twice.
- Use matching wrapping so the gifts look the same.
- Read the rules aloud before you start, and keep them short.
- Assign someone to watch the clock if your group is big.
- Take photos of the gifts before they are unwrapped, because people forget what they opened.
Planning the evening
Most gift exchange parties need an hour and a half. Spend ten minutes on arrivals and drinks, five on reading the rules, up to an hour on the game, and the rest on food and conversation. Keep a printed copy of the rules near the gifts so late arrivals can catch up without stopping the game. Put the gifts in one corner as people arrive, and mark the order of play on a card or a screen. If you are running more than one game, start with the quickest one to warm people up, and finish with the stealing game when everyone is relaxed. See the office party games page for ideas to add around the exchange.
White elephant (Yankee swap)
Everyone brings a wrapped gift. Players take turns opening or stealing. Gifts freeze after three steals.
Tip: Set a steal limit and ban the immediate steal-back. Hollyhush tracks it for you.
Learn more →Secret Santa
Each person is assigned one other person to buy for, and gifts are exchanged on the day.
Tip: Add exclusions for couples and use wishlists so gifts land well.
Learn more →The dice game
Everyone brings a gift. Players roll dice in turn. Specific numbers mean swapping with the left or right, or opening a new gift. When the timer ends, you keep what you hold.
Tip: Great with kids, fast and full of laughs. Use a 15-minute timer.
Learn more →Pass-the-gift story
Read a story with "left" and "right" in it. Each time you hear one, pass the gift that way. The gift you hold at the end is yours.
Tip: Write the story yourself with your group's inside jokes.
Learn more →Reverse white elephant
All the gifts are open from the start. Players choose or steal from the table, then everyone gets a final swap.
Tip: It rewards the people who bring beautiful gifts.
Learn more →Guess the giver
Gifts are numbered, opened one at a time and the group guesses who brought each.
Tip: Add small clues on the tags. Everyone gets a gift and a game.
Learn more →Secret Santa with a reveal
Run a Secret Santa, but keep the names hidden until the party. People guess who had them before the reveal.
Tip: Hollyhush can hide names until a date you pick.
Learn more →Gift bingo
Each player gets a card of gift types ("something warm", "something edible"). When the gift you open matches a square, mark it. First to complete a line chooses a gift next.
Tip: Print cards from the group chat and make it a casual race.
Learn more →Left, Right, Center gift pass
Everyone brings a wrapped gift and sits in a circle with it in front of them. Roll a die marked with left, right and center (or use three dice with L, R and C faces and dots). Left or right means pass your gift that way, center means it goes to the middle pile, and a dot means keep it.
Tip: Agree on a timer first. When it ends, everyone keeps what is in front of them and the center pile is shared out by a last roll.
Learn more →Chinese auction (raffle tickets)
Gifts sit on a table. Everyone gets the same number of raffle tickets, or buys them for charity. Players drop tickets into the cup beside the gifts they want, then one ticket is drawn from each cup and that person takes the gift.
Tip: Say up front that one person can win more than one gift, or give winners a skip so gifts spread out.
Learn more →Themed gift swap
Run a normal white elephant or Secret Santa, but every gift must fit one theme: books, snacks, cozy night in, handmade, or something from your own kitchen. A shared theme makes gifts feel fair and easier to shop for.
Tip: Pick the theme in the invite and set a price cap, so no one has to guess what counts.
Learn more →Mystery gift bags
Gifts go in identical opaque bags, not wrapping paper. Players pick a bag by number and open it, with no steals, so there is no waiting and no hurt feelings. For a twist, allow one swap per person after everything is open.
Tip: Use matching bags and tissue so nobody can guess a gift by its shape.
Learn more →Twelve days of Christmas count-up
Each Secret Santa leaves one small item for their person on each of 12 days, usually starting on December 13 and ending on the 24th. The items can follow the song (one, two, three and so on) or just be tiny gifts in a daily bag.
Tip: Cap the total spend, for example $24 for all twelve days, or the pace gets expensive fast.
Learn more →Book exchange
Everyone wraps one book they love and writes a one-line teaser on the outside, with no title. Players draw numbers, then pick or steal a wrapped book like white elephant, and swap titles later if they like.
Tip: Ask people to bring a book they have actually read, so every gift is a real recommendation.
Learn more →Cookie swap
Each guest brings a dozen cookies for each person attending, plus a recipe card. Everyone fills a box from the table, so you leave with a mix of treats.
Tip: Label anything with nuts, and ask guests to bring a different cookie type so the table is not all chocolate chip.
Learn more →Secret Santa clue chain
Each Santa leaves a small gift for their person on several days, with a clue about themselves attached each time. The person you buy for tries to guess who you are before the reveal, and some groups call the giftee-hunts-the-giver version a reverse Secret Santa.
Tip: Make the first clue easy and the last one nearly obvious so the guessing stays fun, not stressful.
Learn more →Wrapping paper ball
Wrap small prizes into a ball of plastic wrap or paper. Players pass the ball around a circle while music plays. When the music stops, the person holding it unwraps layers, keeping any prize they find, until the music starts again.
Tip: Hide a mix of small treats and silly items so the ball feels fair, and ask kids not to rip the whole thing apart.
Learn more →Frequently asked questions
Which gift exchange game is best for a large group?
White elephant with a steal limit of 1 or 2, or the dice game. Both keep play moving.
Which is best for kids?
The dice game or pass-the-gift story. They're quick and everyone gets a gift.
Which is best when people can't attend?
Secret Santa with a shipping deadline, plus a video call to open gifts.
What is the easiest gift exchange game to run?
Secret Santa with a link-based draw is the easiest: no one needs to bring a gift to the table, and each person only buys one present.
Try it now
A draw takes about a minute. No signup, no email, a private link for everyone.
Create your group, free- Couples & exclusions
- Wishlists & anonymous questions
- Deletes itself in 60 days
Ready when you are
Make a draw in a minute. No signup, no email, private links for everyone.
Start with: How Secret Santa works · Anonymous Secret Santa · How much to spend